Skip to content

(317) 491-1050
  • Home
  • About
  • FAQ & Resources
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • Counties
    • Boone County
    • Hendricks County
    • Hamilton County
    • Hancock County
    • Johnson County
    • Monroe County
    • Elkhart County
    • St. Joseph County
    • Delaware County
    • Marion County
  • Contact
  • Locations

40 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE

Our collaborative approach allows us to see a case from various
angles to identify all legal defenses.
  • Criminal Law
  • Federal Crimes & White Collar
  • Drug Crimes
  • Sex Crimes
  • Title IX Litigation
  • Injury & Civil Rights

An Accused Can Face Federal And State Charges For The Same Crime P2

On behalf of Hayes Ruemmele Posted in Federal Crimes June 24, 2016

We are picking up where we left off in our last post. Dylann Roof is the young man who opened fire during a Bible study session at a Charleston, South Carolina church. Nine people died and three were injured. All of the victims were African American, and Roof has alluded to his hope that the shootings would start a race war. Roof now faces charges at both the state and federal levels.

The U.S. Department of Justice was involved very early in the investigation. Within hours of the shootings, federal authorities, including Attorney General Loretta Lynch, were talking to the press about treating the killings as a hate crime or an act of terrorism.

A couple of weeks later, a federal grand jury handed up a 33 count indictment. Roof is charged with murder and attempted murder based on the victims’ race. In addition to being a hate crime, the killings were also a violation of the victim’s right to practice their religion. Finally, the indictment also included weapons charges.

The federal government can pursue a parallel case against Roof because he is accused of breaking a federal law. Broadly speaking, federal courts deal with federal laws, and state courts deal with state laws. Because this crime occurred in South Carolina, Roof is accused of violating state laws; the South Carolina court system has the authority to adjudicate the case.

However, like Indiana, South Carolina does not have a hate crime law. The federal government does. The Justice Department apparently believed that, in the interest of justice, the particulars of the crime demanded a more specific charge, one that more closely met Roof’s alleged intention to start a race war.

So, here, then, we have one example of why parallel prosecutions may occur: The two court systems are prosecuting one person for different crimes that arose from the same act. Please note, though, that this is just one example. There are other situations that could find a suspect dealing with both state and federal charges, but they are material for future posts.

Sources:

ABC News, “Dylann Roof Indicted on Federal Hate Crime Charges in Charleston Church Massacre, Court Documents Say,” Pierre Thomas and Jack Cloherty, July 22, 2015

Washington Post, “Accused Charleston church gunman pleads not guilty but plans to plead guilty to federal hate crime charges,” Jeremy Borden, July 31, 2015


Tagged Federal Crimes
Previous Post: What Is The Clery Act?
Next Post: An Accused Can Face Federal And State Charges For The Same Crime

Categories

  • Criminal Defense (11)
  • Drug Crimes (13)
  • Federal Crimes (8)
  • Injuries (1)
  • Sex Crimes (9)
  • Uncategorized (2)

Archives

  • February 2018 (2)
  • September 2017 (2)
  • August 2017 (2)
  • July 2017 (2)
  • June 2017 (2)
  • May 2017 (5)
  • January 2017 (1)
  • November 2016 (1)
  • June 2016 (26)

Recent Posts

  • DOES THE STATE SAY IT IS YOUR DNA?
  • What happens when you get arrested in Indianapolis?
  • The first question Indianapolis murder defense attorneys have to answer: “Will I get bond?”
  • What You Need To Know About Rape, by Indianapolis Sex Crime Attorney Jane Ruemmele
  • Federal or State? – Common Questions That Indianapolis Criminal Defense Attorneys Are Asked

Tags

About Us Car Crash Civil Recovery Criminal Charges Criminal Defense Criminal Defense Attorney Deviate Conduct Drug Charges Drug Crimes Drunk Driving Federal Crimes Internet Pornography Marijuana Rape RapeX Sexual Battery Sex Crimes Sexual Assault Video

Learn How We Can Help

You do not need to navigate the court system alone. When you work with us, your problem becomes ours. At Hayes Ruemmele LLC, we do things differently by using a holistic and inclusive approach. We will work with you and your family to obtain the help needed to get through a difficult time.

Call (317) 491-1050 or send us an email to schedule an appointment with us. An initial consultation is free of charge.

Jane Ruemmele Charles Hayes

Hayes Ruemmele, LLC
22 E Washington Street Ste. 610
Indianapolis IN 46204
Phone: (317) 491-1050
Indianapolis Law Office Map

Everybody Deserves A Right To A Defense.
Get Your Free Initial Consultation.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Hayes Ruemmele LLC, focuses on criminal defense and civil rights litigation in Indianapolis, Marion County and throughout Indiana.

© 2020 by Hayes Ruemmele LLC. All rights reserved. Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy